Friday, February 12, 2010

100 Years A Part - Similar Message?

Although I am only halfway through Upton Sinclair's novel, "The Jungle", I can't help but find similar ideas to those presented in "In Defense of Food", by Michael Pollan. Upton Sinclair sheds a gruesome light on the meat industry in Chicago at the turn of the 20th century. He is perhaps one of the first authors to grab the public's attention by the horns and to force the investigation of food handling and processing. His story follows that of a Lithuanian family living and working in Chicago's meatpacking district. The trials of the family mirror those of the meat industry itself. The final product is never as pure as when it began its journey through the factories. In fact, it is far from pure with the addition of chemicals, disease, dirt, germs and many more foreign elements that should not be allowed into food. The novel incites the fears of its readers and eventually generates the insistence of better food inspection and food handling policies. Like Michael Pollan, Upton Sinclair forces us all to take a second look at the food we put on our plates and to reflect upon its story.

Michael Pollan takes a step back from the evolutionary track of food
science and "nutritionism" to question where we are heading as far as the
food that we (sometimes blindly) choose to put in our bodies. He examines the issue that food is more than the summation of its nutritional parts. Food must be looked at as a whole: from the composition of the soil and environment in which it was grown, the processing or lack of processing it endured along the way, to the other food with which it is
consumed as a meal. He warns against food marketers' labels that try to entice us to eat "heart healthy" and "low fat" foods, as well as food that should be straight forward, but instead contains ingredients that can't be pronounced or understood without a PhD in Nutritional Labeling. Michael Pollan also visits (because it's a somewhat scary reality) the consequences of the now staple "western diet", i.e., diabetes, heart disease and obesity.

Where has our growing knowledge of food taken us and where did we take a wrong turn? If we have a better understanding of food now, down to its smallest, molecular details, why then have we developed the western diseases that seem to stem from unhealthy eating? Pollan offers some historical reflections as far as US legislation on food production and marketing (tell us what we're eating and don't put anything "fake" in it!). The, "eat this, not that - go this way, no that way", directions of nutritionists don't offer any long-term support to eaters either. So where to next? To begin, we need to revisit those things called fruits and vegetables: those foods that express mother nature's voice through sight, smell and taste (the senses that should be consulted when ingestion is involved). This isn't a doorway to vegetarian world by any means. It is only a simple suggestion that the produce section of your local grocery establishment might offer more beneficial (and real) food than the isles containing boxed, highly processed food. If the ingredient list for your bread reads far beyond flour, water, salt and yeast, then count the number of ingredients (and try to say them) that follow. Check out your diet as a whole. Like a single food, more can be gained (hopefully not weight) by looking at your diet as an ecosystem, the interaction and relationship of components, not just french fry / ketchup. Support your local farmers and visit the farmers market before heading off to the grocery store. As Michael Pollan might suggest, you'll be hard-pressed to find a whole lot of adulterated food or the most popular ingredient, high fructose corn syrup, at the farmers market.

No, all of the "answers" can not be found in "In Defense of Food", but this book does offer an opportunity to open your eyes a little wider when you next open your mouth to eat. So, keep on reading as you keep on eating, food.

No comments:

Post a Comment